released from jail
Philadelphia Grannies Coming Out Of Jail - June 28, 2006

Home
Articles about us
Other articles
Legislative Action
Legislative Sites
Granny Events Upcoming
Past
Related Actions
and Vigils

Photos
Songs
Downloads
Allies
Contact us
Advanced search
Granny T-Shirts & Buttons
Bios of 11 Granny Enlistees
Arrested June 28, 2006
Mission Statement

We are here because whenever we encounter war grandmothers must work to insure peace for all children and grandchildren.


We are here to fight against the loss of civil liberties and human rights and the wars that result when democratic principles are broken.


We are here now because we are outraged by the deaths of American troops and Iraqi citizens in a senseless war


We are Granny Peace Brigade Philadelphia.

Join Us
We welcome all ages, women and men, grandparents or not.

AMERICAN GRANNIES EXPRESS OUTRAGE AFTER 5 YEARS OF WAR;

Grandmothers in 20 Cities Protest Occupation; Some Get Arrested

    With knitting needles, with dirty linen clotheslines, many with songs, and some with acts of civil disobedience, grandmother groups across the United States in at least 20 cities expressed their frustration, their deep rage at the continued occupation of Iraq.  This was the granny way of commemorating the end of five years since the bombing of Iraq on March 19, 2003.

    The coordinated granny actions, initiated by the Granny Peace Brigade in New York City, were the latest ones demonstrating once again that the grandmothers of America have been in the forefront of the peace movement since Day One of the U.S. catastrophic invasion of a sovereign nation.

    Perhaps the most noteworthy of the protests was that carried out in Atlanta, Georgia, on March 17, where 10 members of the Atlanta Grandmothers for Peace were arrested and jailed for 10 hours when they attempted to enlist in the military at a recruiting center.  Said Doris Benit, 80, one of the arrestees:  "We believe our young people were sent to Iraq on a web of lies and deceit.  We believe they are being used as cannon fodder in an illegal and unjustified war against a nation which posed no threat to us.”

    Very whimsical Knit-Ins for Peace were held in New York City, Washington DC, Pittsburgh PA, and other cities.  They were outdoor events which involved grandmothers knitting stump socks for amputee veterans.  The New York Granny Peace Brigade valiantly knit in the rain for about two hours outside the Times Square recruiting center where they had been arrested and carted off to jail in 2005 for attempting to enlist, while calling out the numbers of dead and wounded from each state.  The oldest granny, and perhaps the most vociferously protesting one there, was 93-year-old Marie Runyon.  Part of the New York group, along with some members of the Granny Peace Brigade Philadelphia and Maryland women, went to Washington, where they knit in rocking chairs outside the Veterans Administration, and when they had completed knitting a number of the stump covers, had a Veteran for Peace color guard hand them over to a VA official.  Fifteen Pittsburgh grannies, the oldest of which is 84, participated in their Knit-In at a recruiting station, as pictured below.
Pittsburgh

(Pittsburgh grandmothers knitting at a local recruiting center March 19, 2008; photo by Bonnie Fortune)

    Another creative demonstration was that in Philadelphia, where the grannies hung a laundry line at City Hall and hung the dirty linen of the Bush administration on it -- each item of clothing inscribed with a plea to correct the many wrongs of the Government  The Philly grannies, like most of the other granny groups, sang anti-war songs during their protests.
Philly

 (some of the dirty linen hung at City Hall in Philadelphia PA March 19, 2008.

photo by Cathy Clemens)

    In Orange County, NY, a group of grandmas met with State University students on campus in Middletown, and urged them to participate in the anti-war movement.  In spite of pouring rain, there was a good turnout and the students were surprisingly receptive.  The older women had a sense that young people are beginning to take more action in the struggle to end the war.

    150 people stood on four corners in Sarasota, Florida.  Eight stalwart grandmothers in Boston held a vigil on Boston Common in a drenching downpour. Other groups that participated were in Spokane; Minneapolis; Detroit; Albany NY; Monkato MN; San Francisco; Montpelier VT; San Jose CA; Bloomington IND; Portland, Maine; St. Augustine FL, and Denver.
Arizona

(Raging Grannies in Tucson AZ hold Knit-In for Peace on March 19, 2008) 

Amazingly, a lot of the granny protests got wide media coverage in their areas.  This represents a kind of breakthrough, as it has been difficult to get publicity for the many grandmother anti-war activities conducted over the last five years since the war was launched..

    At least two grandmothers got arrested when a group of protesters prevented entrance to the IRS in Washington DC  -- Beverly Rice of the New York Granny Peace Brigade and Sue Gracey of the Boston Raging Grannies. 

    When grandmothers are willing to risk arrest and jail, as so many of us old ladies do on a regular basis these days, you know this war is despised and must be ended.  We grannies are not getting any younger and our energy is not what it was in our earlier days -- but we keep on keeping on knowing we will not be here forever and earnestly hoping that we are inspiring other and younger people to carry on our urgent quest when we no longer can.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Biden Challenged by Granny J
ean Haskell
Philadelphia Evening Bulletin - August 28, 2007
Full Story

--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Granny letter published in local paper

Outraged by war

As a member of the Granny Peace Brigade of Philadelphia, I say, Hooray for Sue Niederer and Hooray for The Inquirer for the interview with her Sunday.

Niederer has every right to be outraged - at military recruiters for pulling the wool over young people's eyes, at the Democrats for kowtowing to a dictator, and at the United States' being in Iraq in the first place. We send her heartfelt sympathy for losing her son.

Almost a year ago, 11 grandmothers were arrested for refusing to leave the military recruiting center in Philadelphia. They wanted to enlist, to be sent to Iraq instead of their grandchildren, who have full lives ahead of them. Since that date, more than 1,000 of our young men and women and countless Iraqis have been killed. Senseless, unnecessary deaths.

If enough people express their outrage to Sens. Bob Casey and Arlen Specter for voting for the war funding bill and supporting this illegal, immoral war, the senators may consider changing their minds. Or they may meet Rick Santorum's fate.

Jean Haskell
Philadelphia


TRAVELING WITH THE GRANNIES
BY MARY FRANCES BAUGH

When I was a young Foreign Service wife traveling to our first assignment, Kennedy had just been inaugurated. We had a framed poster of the young president entitled, “There’s a world to be won.” He didn’t mean to win it by preemptive wars, either, and we never stopped believing in diplomacy instead of war. Years disappeared into history and shared memories, but Kennedy’s admonition to ask what you can do for your country was woven into our lives, a strong warp thread, sturdy and sure. Now it was 8:30 A.M. on a cold Wednesday, the 17th of January, at the Chinese bus station. Twenty of us from the Philadelphia Granny Peace Brigade were going to Congress to lobby for an end to the Iraq war. Our black T-shirts bore the motto, “We will not be silent,” inspired by the resistance group, the Society of the White Rose during Germany’s Nazi era.

We boarded the bus and headed for Washington, D.C. I barely knew one or two of the fellow grannies and moreover, I felt ill prepared to be talking to senators and congress people with any authority. The grannies were very well prepared, however, for which I was grateful. We had background information on every congress person and senator from Pennsylvania – how they had voted on Iraq war issues and we just wanted to know where they stood on Bush’s latest attempt to keep his futile and foolish war going. We had an agenda, and hard questions. As a group, represented by grannies from a large contingent from New York, 21 states, as well as our Philadelphians, we were armed with hard facts and righteous indignation, as well as a sense of purpose. It’s hard to beat such a combination for being a force for change. If the Grannies can’t get the peace message across, who can? We felt hopeful.

Will the change come fast enough to save more lives? Here’s what we were asking our elected representatives to work for, from Senators Casey and Specter, Representatives Schwartz, Brady,Fattah, Sestak, Carney, Dent, and Murphy:

1: an immediate withdrawal of troops from Iraq using currently available funding;
2: not to permit any additional funding for the war in Iraq;
3: remove permanent military bases in Iraq;
4: develop a plan to help safeguard and rebuild Iraq.

At 9:00 A.M. on Thursday in the basement of the capitol building, Representative Dennis Kucinich of Ohio, a presidential contender, hosted a press conference during which we heard a gold star mother talk of her dead son’s hopes and dreams, an Iraq war vet, a former Colonel/Foreign Service officer who resigned because of the war, as well as grannies from New York and Philadelphia. By the time we finished chanting, “No more war,” “Bring the troops home,” and “We will not be silent,” the place was rocking. It was a small room, filled with a majority of gray-haired, white-haired women. That Bush hadn’t heard the country at the mid-term elections, hadn’t heard the Baker/Hamilton report, and wasn’t hearing us now was no surprise. My own Granny used to say, “There’s no one so deaf as he who does not wish to hear.” Obviously Bush did not wish to hear our cries for peace now as he began sending more troops the minute after he thought of it, or so it seemed. Without congressional approval, either.

So we were hoping to convince Senators and Congress people of our four point plan. In some cases we were told we were preaching to the choir, and in some cases the grannies seemed to know more than the legislative aides. “I’d have to look it up,” was the response of one aide more than once. Still, he was polite as he hedged on straight answers.

Senator Specter was given a Granny Peace Brigade button from the Philadelphia Grannies when some of them met him on the way into the building. A serendipitous event we couldn’t have anticipated.

With every Senator, we left copies of George McGovern’s book on how to extricate ourselves from Iraq. We left white roses, symbol of our campaign, “We will not be silent,” and we left smiling, strangely hopeful that this branch of government, which has the power of the purse, might just pull the purse strings shut! The lawmakers were reminded that the people of Pennsylvania had spoken in the election and that we the people wanted “out” now, not at some random future date.

Grannies bring our own brand of urgency to the message, however. Our time may be running out and we all know it. We can demand peace. We have absolutely nothing to lose. Our grandchildren have a world to gain. No, “we will not be silent.”

Philadelphia Grannies Arrested

recruiting office

interview

the way

banner


On Wednesday, June 28, 2006, eleven (11) members of Philadelphia Grandmothers for Peace were arrested at the U.S. Military Recruitment office, 125 N. Broad Street and charged with "defiant trespass." It is a summary charge and the 11 Grannies have to appear in court at 8:30am on June 29, 2006, 1401 Arch Street, 2nd floor. Among those arrested were acclaimed poet Sonia Sanchez and wheel-chair bound Lillian Willoughby.

At 12 noon today, the Grannies entered the recruitment office carrying an apple pie for the military recruiters. They informed the sergeant that they had come to enlist and would stay until they were permitted to do so. The women engaged the recruiters in conversation and spoke to several young people who had come to the recruitment to obtain information or to enlist. The recruiters closed the office but the Grannies remained inside until they were arrested by Philadelphia police around 4pm today.

Outside the recruitment center, New York Grannies Brigade for Peace and representatives from Women's International League for Peace and Freedom, Brandywine Peace Community, Philadelphia NOW, United for Peace and Freedom and other peace and justice groups in the Philadelphia region held a rally in support the Philadelphia Grannies.

The Philadelphia Grannies are part of a large network across the United States of grandmothers telling recruiters "Take me to Iraq, not our grandchildren." On Valentine's Day this year, grandmothers in over fifteen cities across the country participated in enlistment actions at recruiting centers. Grannies offer themselves to replace the young men and women needlessly put in harm’s way due to Bush’s occupation of Iraq.

Inspired by the actions of grandmothers in New York City, Tucson, Detroit, Cleveland, Minneapolis, southern Florida and Oakland, Philadelphia Grannies are acting in the tradition of those patriots who dissented from the policies of the King George of England and started the movement for independence. In the city of Philadelphia, the birthplace of a new republic, the Philadelphia Grannies have taken as a basic responsibility the right to dissent, to oppose the use of the military to carry out an irresponsible foreign policy.

The New York Grannies Brigade will leave Philadelphia on June 29th. They will go to Princeton where they will receive a peace award. They then will go to Baltimore and arrive in Washington, D.C. on Independence Day, July 4th. 


By Marlene Santoyo. Photos by Rich Gardner, Philly IMC



Unusual Suspects

PHILADELPHIA  CITY PAPER

Inside the anti-war grannies' siege of the Broad Street recruiting
office.

Tondrel Birgans found himself cornered. Enemy forces blocked his only escape route, so he dug in and assessed the situation. "You have a right as an American to have your opinion," the polite Alabama native told his captors. "My opinion is that I love to serve my country. I love doing what I do.

"You enjoy killing people?" asked one of 11 grandmothers who, intent on making a loud anti-war statement this day, gingerly strode and wheeled into his institutionally sterile recruiting office at Broad and Race streets and claimed the land as their own.

in custody

11 ANGRY WOMEN: After slipping down a hallway into the U.S. Marine recruiting station, Philadelphia Grandmothers for Peace's Sonia Sanchez (right), Zandra Moberg (second from right) and their cohorts listened intently as a civil-affairs police officer explained the arrest process.
All Photos By: Michael T. Regan

"We do not just kill. We serve and protect the country. We're doing what our leaders tell us to do," said Birgans, an 8-year-veteran who then declared, to the women's disdain, that being in the military "has bettered my life. I've learned a lot about myself."

Around and around they went for the next hour or so. The women, ranging in age from mid-50s to early 90s, maintained that war is wrong. That Birgans shouldn't help send young Americans off to their deaths.

Birgans maintained that there would be no freedom but for the nation's enlisted men and women. Brave men and women who fight so these women, and the 75-some anti-war granny supporters who were waiting outside with "No Blood for Oil" and "The Way: Love and Non-Violence" posters, have the right to question authority.

Sensing his words were having little effect—they weren't—Birgans wished the women the best of luck and ceded his position. The women, who graciously cleared him an exit path, noshed on trail mix and strawberries and started discussing their next move.

The siege of the Center City recruiting station was officially on.

Within minutes of Birgans' departure, it was Craig Smith's turn to comprehend a surreal situation. How often does one have to deal with a renegade pack of grandmothers? A pack of grandmothers intent on getting hauled off to jail to make a political statement?

Leaning in the door of the Marine office—which shares space with Army, Navy and Air Force recruiting outfits—Smith checked out a jabberjawed pack of women sporting straw hats and carrying Audubon Society totebags and anti-war literature. A sergeant with the Philadelphia Police Department's civil affairs, Smith had already had a long Wednesday. His day had started some 11 hours before at a Teamsters strike at the Navy Yard.

"Ok, grannies," bellowed Smith, a sweaty, white-haired veteran. "Who wants to go to jail?"

They all answered in the affirmative.

They call themselves the Granny Peace Brigade. On Oct. 17, 2005, some 18 New York City grandmothers marched up to a recruiting station in Times Square to enlist in the military. There had been similar actions in Canada and Tucson, Ariz., so the women knew they wouldn't be permitted to take the place of soldiers already in Iraq. But that wasn't really the point.

city
PAPER CHASE: After Marie Runyon and the rest of the grannies made it to the recruiting station, they angered an Army sergeant by replacing brochures with pictures of flag- draped coffins.
Photo By: Michael T. Regan

Rather, by blocking the door to the recruiting station, they'd get arrested. And getting arrested would beget media attention—who, after all, can resist the story of police locking up elderly women for protesting the war?—which would go a long way toward jump-starting a seemingly stagnant anti-war movement.

True to form, the NYC women became a cause celebre. By the time they beat the rap six months later, they'd inspired local grandmothers Zandra Moberg, Nina Huizinga and Marlene Santoyo to want to ride the groundswell at a time when few young'uns were carrying the anti-war mantle. Thus, the Philadelphia Grandmothers for Peace were born [Philly Blunt, "Grannies Gone Wild," Brian Hickey, June 8, 2006].

It took little time for them to find their opportunity. Since the New York grannies would be coming through town on their way to spend the Fourth of July protesting in Washington, D.C., they decided they'd let the guests watch some dames follow in their cane-assisted footsteps and wheelchair tracks.

So, on a day when 11 insurgent Sunni groups offered to stop attacking U.S. forces if America agreed to pull out of Iraq within two years, 11 grandmothers from Philadelphia met at the Friends Center and led a cavalcade of anti-warriors to the local recruiting office.

The day would prove, if nothing else, to be entertaining.

It all starts at 11:30 a.m. with a bullhorn cry of, "We're on a trek. A trek for peace. We're pleading now to end this war." Through the scorching heat, protesters like Marie Runyon, a legally blind 91-year-old carrying two walking sticks, march down 15th Street, across Arch and up Broad with protest on their minds. Waiting for the formation of chanting grannies to pass, one elderly woman from New York, sporting a yellow "Granny Peace Brigade" pin, gripped her walker and declares, "This is so awesome. I'm so proud to be a part of it."

Minutes later, local founder Moberg is waltzing into the Army office at the recruiting station, where she is met by Sgt. First Class Bell, who, sporting desert-style camos, gets handed an apple pie. "Take it. It might be good," says Moberg. "We're here to enlist." Bell, a strictly business military woman, looks past Moberg, a quick-to-smile, rail-thin grandmother of two sporting a wide-brimmed purple hat. Outside, she sees dozens of protesters congregated on the sidewalk, passing out anti-war pamphlets and singing "God Bless America."

This, she must be thinking, is going to be an interesting day.

Meanwhile, the grannies—one of whom, wheelchair-bound Lillian Willoughby, 91, had already done some jail time for protesting the Iraq war outside the Philadelphia federal building—notice one of Bell's peers talking to a potential recruit.

"Take us," one granny yells from the pack, "not them."

Bell, getting less amused when she realizes someone has replaced recruitment brochures with pictures of flag-draped coffins, explains that they just can't walk in and sign up in five minutes. Besides, she notes, they're all above the 42-year age limit to enlist.

"We'd like to start that process now, anyway," declares one of the grannies.

paddy wagon
BUSTED: Allowed to leave the station without cuffs, the grannies were transported to the 16th District headquarters in the back of two police vans. Charged with defiant trespass, they'll take their anti-war case to the courtroom in December.
Photo By: Michael T. Regan

With the gatekeeper Bell distracted, some of the grannies advance 20 feet down a hallway into the office of Birgans, who, after an hourlong debate, vacates his air-conditioned post to the women.

It is there that Smith finds them and tries to determine just what exactly they are doing.

"What," he asks, "are your general plans?"

"To stop the war," responds Santoyo, a headstrong Mt. Airy resident sporting large, turtle-esque eyeglasses. "And to enlist."

Smith then retreats to the adjacent Army office to formulate an attack plan with the military. They need to act quickly, too, considering that tensions seem to be rising.

At one point, Smith grabs a granny by her arm and hauls her out of the Army office she'd sneaked into, an act of aggression he quickly apologizes for. Soon thereafter, a protester tells a uniformed Army recruiter that a 93-year-old woman needs to use a bathroom. Desperately. The soldier tells them there's one next door. "You mean to tell me there isn't a bathroom in here?" a protester asks.

"There is one," says the soldier, "but you can't use it."

For his part, Smith says he doesn't want to lock anybody up, but the women are intent on forcing his hand. By 1:30 p.m., police lock the doors to the building. Nobody can come in, and anyone who leaves is out for good.

In the Marine office, where the ladies sit peacefully on couches, plastic chairs and on a desk, a Q&A ensues.

"We're staying here until we can enlist," says Santoyo, playing the role of negotiator in a room filled with grandmothers both dreadlocked and white-haired.

"The good sergeant told you that's not possible," responds Smith, referring to the ranking officer of the Army recruiting station, Sgt. Daniel Gager, who, just three days away from finishing his stint of active duty, has since arrived.

"What will we be charged with?"

inside station

"Defiant trespass. It's usually a summary offense. You'll probably be taken down and fingerprinted but it might be a while before you see a judge."

"Will we be held overnight?"

"Not likely."

Smith gives the ladies a moment to privately discuss their options; Santoyo recaps everything, additionally noting that if they're handcuffed, their restraints will only be plastic.

Their resolve strengthens.

"We have a consensus," she announces. "We're staying. We want to get arrested. Are we going to walk out, or get carried?"

One of the grannies jokingly asks whether they can be transported to jail in a stretch limo. The group starts singing "We Shall Overcome" and vows to voice anti-war statements when they're led out of the building.

"Anybody here who needs to go to the bathroom better do it now," says Smith, who's made sure the facilities have been made available to the occupying forces, "because the bathroom in the place you're going is the pits."

With Smith having little luck talking the women out of their mission, Gager tries appealing to their common sense. He tells them their point's been made, but that there's really nothing anybody here can do considering they're not the policy makers. Appeasing them with a stack of "Request for Examination" forms, the documents potential recruits fill out, he appeals to their grandmotherly instincts

"My soldiers in there, they work 80 hours a week, six days a week. They hardly ever see their families and what's happening here today only takes them away from their families that much more," he says, fishing for sympathy that won't be found.

"We're sorry we're making them work more," says Metzler, the granny whose arm isn't hurting anymore.

hat
"You're a symbol to us," says a twentysomething woman who, here on behalf of the Iraq Veterans Against the War, has been railing against the military, trying to convince potential recruits to get as far away from the building as quickly as they can and feeding the grannies verbal ammunition to fire at the uniformed officers.

As a group, the women decide they feel bad, yes, but they cannot apologize for what they've done. War is serious. And so is trying to bring one to an end.

"I'm not here to debate the legality of the war," Gager says. "Can I appeal to you one more time to just leave?"

The answer is no. But that's not what gets Gager riled up. What does that is one woman's comment that American soldiers set out to kill innocent civilians.

"Ma'am," Gager says, his voice rising, "no soldier intentionally kills women and children, and I'm offended you said that."

"We want to make less work for you, not more," one says as he's leaving.

Adds Metzler, "We want to put you out of business."

By 2:45 p.m., reality is setting in. The women have resolved to go to jail, so two female police officers are taking the grannies' information down. "Unfortunately," announces Smith, "from here on out, it's not going to be a pleasant experience for you. You're about to go from having a friendly chat to getting arrested."

After it's announced that the women won't be cuffed, everybody who doesn't intend to go to jail is asked to leave. Outside, the protesters burn time posing for pictures and urging cars to honk. The weight of their situation can be seen in one of their protest signs, the one that kept a tally of U.S. soldiers killed in Iraq has risen from 2,525 to 2,526.

"Troops home now," the women start yelling as the police transport vans arrive. "We stand with our sisters."

At 4:30 p.m., the side doors to the recruiting station spring open and the supporters start chanting, clapping and waving their signs. One by one, 11 grannies are escorted out of the building. Since they're not cuffed, they hyperactively wave their frail arms, throwing peace signs up in the air. The police are careful to gingerly load them into the backs of the vans, what with all the cameras recording their every move. Those in custody are beaming as they applaud their supporters. Their fans can't help but cheer back. Though none of them sings "We Shall Overcome" as planned, they're as happy as someone in custody can be. They smile and pose for pictures in the back of the police vans.

signing

Charged with defiant trespass, an offense on par with jaywalking, they're hauled off to the 16th District station at 39th Street and Lancaster Avenue for processing. (Special dispensation is given to Willoughby, who, since she gets around in a wheelchair, is driven in the back of an unmarked vehicle along with Moberg, who, when asked how she feels as she gets into the cop car, can do nothing but grin.)

The 16th is what you'd expect a West Philly police precinct to look like. Litter strewn across the front of the building. Flies swarming in the hallway leading inside. Posters advertising reward money for those who dime gun toters out

The inside, however, has probably never seen a scene like this. The 11 grannies sit on plastic chairs in a cavernous front room. At a picnic-style table, a few officers run through the jailbirds' information. Behind a bullet-proof window, clerks type up their arrest records.

Chatting amongst themselves, the women look as if they could be waiting for the next game of Bingo to start as their supporters start showing up at the precinct.

One of the New York grannies, talking about how they'll be on to Washington by way of Wilmington at 9 a.m. the next day. She says a point of conversation on their bus ride here was what would happen if one of the grannies died while on the trip: "We all decided that it was OK, since they died doing what they wanted to do."

The process takes all of an hour and the first arrestee to be released is Sue Ellen Klein, a 65-year-old from Center City, at 6:18 p.m. She's greeted by raucous applause.

"They were very gentle," she says of the police officers, "but they told us if we did it again, it'd be more serious."

One by one, the others stroll out. When they leave the processing room, they walk down a flight of steps and out the front door, posing for the obligatory photograph in front of the 16th Police District sign.

Nina Huizinga, an ever-smiling 66-year-old Quaker sporting a flowing, hippie-esque white dress and pink button-up shirt, has lost her sun bonnet. Her curly white hair spirals out in every direction as she pumps her fist in the air proclaiming victory.

She and a fellow jailbird do some Rockette kicks on the front steps. "I'm sooo happy," she says. "This was really a blast."

When the women start comparing their release papers—the ones that have them scheduled for a court appearance at 8:30 a.m. the next morning—they realize whoever processed them must have been colorblind.

Black protesters, like the dreadlocked poet Sonia Sanchez, are listed as Caucasian while whites are listed as black or Asian/Pacific Islander. The laughter doesn't subside for about 10 minutes and the women agree not to tell the police of their mistake as it may come into play when they have to go before the judge.

The last of the Philly grannies is released some seven hours after they seized the recruiting office, and even though there's little fanfare, they act as if they've accomplished a great thing here today. They hope people will hear about what the Philly grannies have done and they'll be driven to rally against the war themselves. Moberg says they've made an important point, put a dent in the war machine.

Plans are made to reunite the groups at some point in the near future before the New York grannies stroll down Lancaster toward a Thai restaurant they'd heard great things about. Santoyo, the lead negotiator, heads for home instead. There's still important work to be done.

On the ride to Mt. Airy, she talks strategy with their attorney David Rudovsky. With so little time until court, the women must decide whether to plead no contest or guilty and do community service, or pay a fine, or plead not guilty and take it to trial.

Urged on by a New York granny who's sharing a ride home, Santoyo agrees that pleading not guilty is the way to go. "We want people to hear what we have to say about the war," she says. "Going to trial is how we do it."

The next morning, they'll plead not guilty to the charges and receive a Dec. 1 court date. But for now, there are more pressing things to tend to. As the car winds up Ridge Avenue, she espies a custard stand and asks if the driver would be kind enough to pull over.

For now, the war can wait.

After the day she's had, nothing would hit the spot more than a small orange and vanilla twist in a cup.



by Brian Hickey

Photographs by Michael T. Regan





Peace grannies rejected for duty in Iraq

PEOPLE'S WEEKLY WORLD

Arrested while insisting to recruiters, ‘Take us, not our grandkids’ 

PHILADELPHIA — As other grannies and their supporters sang peace songs, spoke out against the war and displayed their colorful banners and signs outside a U.S. Armed Forces Center here, 11 grandmothers tried unsuccessfully June 28 to enlist for service in Iraq.
Take us, not Philadelphia’s children and grandchildren,” they told the recruiters. “Let them live their lives.”

pww

The 11, members of the Granny Peace Brigade, were Marlene Santoyo, Helen Evelev, Ruth Balter, Zandra Moberg, Kathleen Sjogren, Sue Ellen Klein, Nina Huizinga, Sylvia Metzler, Gloria Hoffman, Sonia Sanchez and 91-year-old wheelchair user Lillian Willoughby.

Their protest here was part of a pilgrimage from New York City to Washington, D.C., celebrating the recent court victory in which 18 “Raging Grannies” were acquitted of obstructing a recruiting station in Times Square where they had attempted to enlist for duty in Iraq. They arrived at the Gandhi Monument in Washington on July 4 where they were joined by women members of Code Pink for a march to the White House to protest the war.

Though at first the Philadelphia recruiters were inclined to let the grannies apply, they quickly changed their minds, despite Moberg’s gift of an apple pie.

While inside the center, the women talked with two young people who came into the office to enlist. After Gloria Hoffman shared some facts about the Iraq war and the deaths of over 2,500 soldiers, high school senior Christine Watson, 17, decided to think more about her decision.

An 18-year-old recent high school graduate told the women his mother was OK with his decision to join the Army. “But what about your grandmother?” they asked.

Both the young people were African American, and unemployment among African American youth is currently over 40 percent here.

The grannies told the young people why they are opposed to war, “especially this war of terror, this war of error,” in the words of one of them.

Santoyo said: “We need a Department of Peace. It’s Afghanistan and Iraq today — will it be Iran next, or North Korea or Cuba? The billions of dollars spent on war could go to schools and health care.”

Turning to the recruiters, Sanchez, a noted poet and author, asked, “My brother, my sister, how do you feel about being in the service?” All replied in the affirmative, citing serving and protecting their country as their reasons for joining. Marine Staff Sgt. Tondrel Birgans told the women the military had bettered his life.

“Do you enjoy enlisting people to be taught how to kill other people?” Willoughby countered from her wheelchair.

Outside the center, Kelly Dougherty, a young woman veteran who served in Iraq, told a very different story about her military service. She recalled being told never to go to the bathroom alone and always to take a female soldier with her. “Rape is rampant in Iraq,” Dougherty said, adding, “When it is reported, many times no one follows up and investigates.”

Telling the women he had to leave for an appointment, Sgt. Birgans suggested they leave, too. “We are here to enlist,” they replied. A Police Department civil affairs officer then gave them two options — leave or be arrested. Soon afterwards the 11 were arrested, escorted into two police vans and taken to a police station.

“We were treated courteously and not handcuffed,” Santoyo said. “They took our information and issued our citations.” The next day the grannies appeared in court and pleaded not guilty. Their trial has been set for Dec. 1.

Outside the recruiting center a contingent of the Granny Peace Brigade from New York City, on their way to the July 4 Washington, D.C., vigil, joined their Philadelphia sisters and supporters in singing familiar songs with new lyrics by the grannies, such as “God Help America,” “Study War No More” and “Let Our Children Grow!”

Holding a large photo of her son, Sgt. Sherwood Baker, killed in Iraq in 2004, Celeste Zappala of Military Families Speak Out noted the rise of U.S. troop deaths in Iraq to 2,527. “If they were the children of the privileged class, this war would be over,” she said.

Asked why and how these grandmothers are able to do what they are doing, Santoyo replied, “It’s not about us. We are reaching out. Older people and all people can make a contribution to build the peace movement. We have to put our life on the line for justice.”

The grannies are seasoned activists. Santoyo, Metzler, Sjogren and Willoughby were among the 160 people who closed down the federal building when the war began in March 2003. They served one week in jail for that action. It was Willoughby’s first act of civil disobedience, at age 89.

“So many people are opposed to this war. It’s time for them to take to the streets,” Santoyo said.

Rosita Johnson
phillyrose623@verizon.net
(from People's Weekly World Newspaper, 07/06/06, http://www.pww.org/article/view/9435/1/)